Reviews

Excellent local old school pizza joint. Family run. Consistent. Fresh. Clean. Friendly. Everything is pretty much the same as it was when my wife grew up here 30 years ago. Wonderful salad bar and affordable lunch specials.

bill cashin via google.com - Jun 28, 2022

Pizza and salad bar were good.

Jason Greene via google.com - Jun 27, 2022

Always love the salad bar at Pizza Man.

Sharon Aldridge via google.com - May 22, 2022

This is a very good place to stop and get a bite to eat.. Very reasonable prices. Really good place to bring the family to eat.. Every single staff member is very respectful even if they are crazy busy.. I would highly recommend this place....

Ryan Becker via google.com - May 21, 2022

I always look forward to their uniquely flavored Pizza and their awesome salad bar with fair prices and a friendly staff.

Dennis Ricketts via google.com - May 6, 2022

We were just passing through and wanted something sit down but quick, yummy and family friendly. We loved the pizza and the experience! Everyone was so friendly! Ordering was quick and food came out fast too! Definitely would recommend and we will be back if we come through this way again!

Camilla Day via google.com - May 1, 2022

Pizza was great. From out of town usually ordering pizza when out of town doesn't end well. But this was one of the best pizzas I've had. 😁 ... read more

Chris Miller via google.com - Mar 20, 2022

We visited tonight for the first time and were very impressed! Salad was great! Garlic bread was ve

We visited tonight for the first time and were very impressed! Salad was great! Garlic bread was very tasty and hot! The pizza was dynamite and so much for the value! we will definitely be back. Quick service.

Gina Goldsmith via facebook.com - Mar 5, 2022

Always great pizza and appetizers! Even though we order Togo we still never miss the trip to the salad bar that always comes with their "Lunch Special". This is kinda fooling name because you can have this special anytime their open and if you get Togo you can either make the trip yourself with a container provided or have them make ... read more

Stacy “The Clean Queen” Byers via google.com - Feb 28, 2022

Great place! Great food! Great service!

Brandi Spence via google.com - Feb 18, 2022

Excellent pizzas! Excellent service and staff! Eat there often and comes out great! 5 stars!

Nathan Maroon via facebook.com - Jan 14, 2022

I don't like to leave bad reviews but I feel as though this needs to be mentioned. My boyfriend and

I don't like to leave bad reviews but I feel as though this needs to be mentioned. My boyfriend and I placed a delivery order for one pizza and were told it would be about 30-35 minutes. We waited one hour since we had called and placed the order, so we called for an update and were told the driver had left and should be there any mi ... read more

Lorene Gentry via facebook.com - Jan 6, 2022

Always busy when I visit from out of town. Good pizza with thin crust. There is also a salad bar. It's really good pizza. Not top tier but really good. Most impressed with how hard the group of young kids work at their jobs.

Jason Bowers via google.com - Dec 2, 2021

It’s quick cheap food and the salad bar is not half bad!

JeremyandSarah Henderson via facebook.com - Nov 25, 2021

Great food ... read more

Tom Wendling via google.com - Nov 18, 2021

Food was good the service was good was worth the trip ... read more

Jeremiah Mcelwee via google.com - Oct 29, 2021

This place is amazing!!! It was very busy but the staff remained friendly and worked diligently on each order. Very organized. We don't have anything like this in my home town unfortunately. The Italian sub was a bit salty but thick with meats. We drove over an hour to try this place....worth it.

Michelle via google.com - Sep 25, 2021

Great pizza, great value, and great service.

Steve Kovacs via google.com - Sep 22, 2021

Was from down South on a road trip. 3 of us got pizza, salad bar, and drinks for only $21. Our veggie pizza was so good.

Courtney Lemasters via google.com - Aug 11, 2021

I use to attend tradeshows in Effingham. I looked forward to each year just to order my pizza. Atmosphere, price, and service all get good to great marks. The pizza is amazing.

AJ Man via google.com - Aug 4, 2021

This was a great stop for pizza on our way through town. Small business atmosphere, family friendly and good food ... read more

Brenda Fassnacht via google.com - Aug 1, 2021

We stopped here to grab some food on our way home. I'm glad we did. The place was packed and they were super busy but it was worth the wait. The staff was friendly and the food was great. I'm glad we got 2 pizzas since we loved it so much. People must have thought we were starving we were eating so fast! Luckily I remembered to grab ... read more

michael fassnacht via google.com - Jul 30, 2021

Good food nice salad bar ... read more

Lisa Nail via google.com - Jul 29, 2021

Great pizza, super quick. I really enjoyed the sign out front and logo. 😂

Great pizza, super quick. I really enjoyed the sign out front and logo. 😂 ... read more

Aiko Kotori via facebook.com - Jun 15, 2021

Happened to be in town, and was looking for a place to eat. Always looking for local places. I or

Happened to be in town, and was looking for a place to eat. Always looking for local places. I ordered wings (cooked perfectly not crispy, or undercooked), cheesy bread (small but very flavorful), and their supreme (square cut, great for portion control). It was all good. Add to that, there was an issue with my credit card number ... read more

Brandon Joseph via facebook.com - May 30, 2021

The very best thin crust pizza money can buy..🙃

The very best thin crust pizza money can buy..🙃 ... read more

Rusty Gass via facebook.com - May 28, 2021

Good price if you go with the "lunch special". I believe you can order that all day. The sauce is a little bland but still overall good for the price. Salad is about average but also good for the price. Overall a solid place to eat at.

Dylan Einhorn via google.com - May 18, 2021

Great prices and food ... read more

Jerry Harris via google.com - May 3, 2021

Good food for an excellent price ... read more

Michael Turner via google.com - Apr 18, 2021

Good prices and the pizza was very very good!

Sarah Griffith via google.com - Apr 13, 2021

Hometown feel. Great pizza and salad bar.

Shelby Hubbart via google.com - Apr 12, 2021

Pizza is a solid 7 and salad bar is nice touch compared to a small side salad ... read more

Creeds way via google.com - Apr 3, 2021

Delicious ... read more

Firestarter via google.com - Mar 18, 2021

OMG! Wow!This place is so unbelievably good!

OMG! Wow! This place is so unbelievably good!

Scott Thoele via facebook.com - Feb 20, 2021

BEST PIZZA IN TOWN!!! Salad bar is great.

Becca Powers via google.com - Feb 19, 2021

Some of the best pizza in town!

YOLOIST54 Gaming via google.com - Feb 19, 2021

Seriously, we stop at Effingham a few times a year , it's about halfway between house in northern Wisconsin and house in Tennessee. And every time we stop , pizza man is an absolute must!!! Wish I had one in Tennessee, but until then, its Effingham stop on every trip ... read more

jimmy wagner via google.com - Jan 23, 2021

The salad is mouthwatering 🤤 ... read more

Tess McLean via google.com - Jan 2, 2021

Beautifully renovated!

Jeff Deters via google.com - Dec 8, 2020

The taste of there pizza is what I like so when I want a pizza i go to The Pizza Man.

RJ Behrman via google.com - Nov 11, 2020

As the box says, it's the best pizza in town. Awesome salad bar. And a great staff! My go to for pizza.

Mathew Gardewine via google.com - Nov 5, 2020

The food was spectacular. Would visit again anytime we're in the area. The staff on the phone was a little less then pleasant and may need some training on your menu.

Jocelyne Cashmore via google.com - Oct 20, 2020

hands down my favorite ... read more

June Solomon via google.com - Oct 2, 2020

It's a great place to have lunch. They serve you quickly. The pizza and salad are both delicious. Employes are friendly and helpful.

Randy Smith via google.com - Sep 27, 2020

Great flavor on the pizza!! Salad bar was awesome! Live out of town but will return when I get the chance!

Kate Bushue via google.com - Sep 19, 2020

Best pizza I have ever ate ... read more

Diamond Anderson via google.com - Sep 13, 2020

Best pizza, in Effingham ... read more

Melody Smith via google.com - Sep 6, 2020

My dad (Jim Kenney) started pizza man in Effingham way, way back. My Mom has many, many pictures of

My dad (Jim Kenney) started pizza man in Effingham way, way back. My Mom has many, many pictures of me and my brother and sister there. It makes me smile that it's still open and doing well. My Dad passed away in 2009, so to see the Pizza Man sign is still the same after all these years is absolutely wonderful! If I ever get a chance ... read more

Kimberly Stephenson via facebook.com - Aug 27, 2020

Small salad bar but very good pizza very good ... read more

Grace Gormley via google.com - Aug 26, 2020

Food was AWESOME as usual. THANKS FOR YOUR AMAZING PIZZA.

Bev Boldrey via google.com - Jul 19, 2020

Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?

Reviews

Follow Us

Navigation

Hours

Contact